Scheduled Maintenance Notice: H2O will be undergoing maintenance on Weds, July 30. Some features may be temporarily unavailable during this period. Thank you for your understanding.

Main Content

Criminal Law

Murder v. Voluntary Manslaughter

Voluntary manslaughter is a common law concept whereby an intentional killing is reduced from murder to manslaughter because the killing occured after an adequate provocation and before a suffienct cooling time had passed. The traditional approach to provocation is set forth in the more modern case, Girourard: only certain provocative acts would suffice to reduce an intentional killing from murder to manslaughter. By contrast, the modern approach is set forth in the older case, Maher: Juries should decide whether a reasonable person in the defendant's position would have been provoked under the circumstances. As we read these cases and the MPC approach, consider whether voluntary manslaughter is a sensible concept and, if so, how it should be delimited.